Heather Wolpert-Gawron

Pannello blog

The Argh Wall! Celebrating Failure in the Classroom: A Lesson For Writing & Making

By on May 15, 2016

So, I’ve been writing lately about my new class that I’m developing for next year called Make Writing.  I’ve been writing curriculum for this class that leverages 3D printing in order to teach Literacy and Writing.  The class itself is made up of many of our students who have, up until now, been detached from more traditional education.  They are the ones at risk for dropping out.  They are the ones being left behind by life.  My school, however, wants to attack their disengagement in a different way, and that’s where this class comes in.  We’re hoping that the Making aspect of this class helps to make learning more meaningful, more hands-on, and overall, more engaging.  After all, student engagement is the key.  As Kelly Gallagher says, Engagement first, then Content, then Rigor.

I’ve also written about the challenges of learning 3D printing myself.  You see, I’m leveraging my own ignorance as a model of how to learn, and the kids are finding that I learn this tech far slower than they do. But while the hardware is out of my wheelhouse, Language Arts is not.  So I’ve begun developing the lessons that will become our benchmark writing assignments, ongoing journal prompts, as well as informal and formal assessments for the next school year.

The Argh Wall!  is one of the first writing lessons I conceived for the class.  It embraces the failures that come with 3D printing as well as the failures that sometimes come with the writing process.  After all, if you think of writing as tinkering, then failure is just another way of saying “feedback prior to revision.”

Here is the lesson, the standards it hits based on 8th-grade Literacy and Writing, and a student sample to help you model for your students.   I picture it as an ongoing assignment that students contribute to as failures happen.  It’s a wall of student work that rotates depending on the projects that are under way and the progress that’s being made on any given piece of work.  It’s a way for them to reflect, plan a next strategy of attack, and be assessed on constructed response writing.  You can also access the file to make your own copy at www.tinyurl.com/ArghWall.

Argh Wall

A picture of the current Argh! Wall

 

The ARGH! Wall

Created by Heather Wolpert-Gawron (aka “Tweenteacher”) This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution, Non-commercial 4.0 International License

Overview: In this writing assignment, students will adopt a growth mindset by celebrating their failures through reflection and challenging themselves to come up with next steps.

As students work using 3D printing, it is not uncommon to fail. With each failure, however, students should be encouraged to look at the steps it took to create the print, note what worked, and propose tweaks to the process before getting back up again.

Students will create a constructed response outline that shares information about their specific print, talks about their goal, and honestly shares what went wrong. For the purpose of this assignment, students are permitted to use appropriate voice to vent their frustration. They are also encouraged to use the vocabulary specific to 3D modeling and printing (extruder, nozzle, retraction, build-plate, bed, etc…)

Constructed Response Outline:

  1. Main Topic Sentence – What went wrong?
  2. Expand on Main Topic Sentence – What is the overview of the project
  3. Evidence of failure – What specifically happened that led to the failure of the print? What problems could you observe in the outcome of the print? (hairy printing, stringing, didn’t stick to the bed, etc…) You can include a photo, descriptions of your observations, specific descriptions of what you attempted (numbers from the tablet) as evidence.
  4. Commentary – Prediction, Relate to the problem, Connect this to something else
  5. Conclusion – How can you move on?

Finally, the student should end on 1-3 bullets to propose next steps.

My Example:

 This Pyramid of Giza was a failed print, but a successful lesson learned.  Not only did the painter’s tape warp immediately, but it was obvious from the start that this was going to affect the entire build.  As you can see from the picture, the letters got squished and the layers didn’t flatten properly.  I didn’t waste time shutting it down so that it didn’t waste filament or time.  It was yet another failed print using blue ABS filament, and I wonder if that dye has something to do with the layers not “stacking” right.  My next steps to solve this problem (I hope):

  • Cry. Just kidding.
  • Find out how to lower the temperature of a heated bed so maybe the tape stays flat
  • Try the same print in a different color

 

Standards: (Note: standards here reflect the Grade 8 standard for Literacy and Writing but can be reflected for all middle and high school level artifacts)

CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RL.8.1 – Cite the textual evidence that most strongly supports an analysis of what the text says explicitly as well as inferences drawn from the text.

CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.W.8.2 – Write informative/explanatory texts to examine a topic and convey ideas, concepts, and information through the selection, organization, and analysis of relevant content.

CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.W.8.2.A -Introduce a topic clearly, previewing what is to follow; organize ideas, concepts, and information into broader categories; include formatting (e.g., headings), graphics (e.g., charts, tables), and multimedia when useful to aiding comprehension.

CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.W.8.2.B – Develop the topic with relevant, well-chosen facts, definitions, concrete details, quotations, or other information and examples.

CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.W.8.2.C – Use appropriate and varied transitions to create cohesion and clarify the relationships among ideas and concepts.

CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.W.8.2.D – Use precise language and domain-specific vocabulary to inform about or explain the topic.

CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.W.8.2.F – Provide a concluding statement or section that follows from and supports the information or explanation presented.

CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.W.8.10 – Write routinely over extended time frames (time for research, reflection, and revision) and shorter time frames (a single sitting or a day or two) for a range of discipline-specific tasks, purposes, and audiences.

 

Student Sample:

Ashley T.
Language Arts
Period 7
3/30/16

ARGH! Paragraph

You know, I’d expect these magical “voodoo” like printers to do an extraordinary job with making my invention, but when I first saw the print out, I didn’t see my invention in all its glory–instead, I got a flippin’ hairy box looking back at me. Unnecessary filament strings hanging everywhere. Come on, this ugly thing isn’t even mine! This print was supposed to be a 3D prototype for my invention (for the Invention Convention), but I can’t even use this. As a matter of fact, my invention is supposedly going to be manufactured with a 3D printer, but after seeing this, I’m very discouraged to do so. After doing some research, thank you very much, I found out that this was a problem that many printers have, known as “stringiness”. It seems to be caused by nozzles that move too slow and temperatures that are too hot. After seeing this, we attempted to change the nozzle temperature to 210 degrees and the build plate temperature to 70 degrees, but the results varied with different types of filament. For example, the red filament seemed to produce perfect results, but the blue and silver (especially silver) had not-so-great prints. Does this mean that the filament itself contributes to stringiness? Perhaps different colors call for different settings? Next, we decided to reprint my invention once more (with the red filament). The results did not meet to my expectation, but it was better than before. Still, there are strings…ARGH!!!! I suppose I could continue to tinker around with the printer’s settings to get a perfect print or I could simply use something else to make my 3D prototype.

The next attempts to solving this problem, as recommended by 3D Verkstan’s website, would be:

  • Turn the nozzle temperature down to 180 degrees.
  • Change (increase) travel speed to 250mm/m.
  • Change the filament–after changing the nozzle temperature to 210 degrees and the build plate temperature to 70 degrees, I think the problem might be in the filament.

 

Works Cited

“A Visual Ultimaker Troubleshooting Guide.” – 3DVerkstan Knowledge Base. Web. 30 Mar. 2016.

            <http://support.3dverkstan.se/article/23-a-visual-ultimaker-troubleshooting-guide>

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Pannello blog

Past, Present, Future: Assessments and Technology

By on April 2, 2016

“Grading, in kids’ brains, parents’ brains, administrators’ brains, and even teachers’ brains, is a final snapshot after which there is no beyond.  But if we can start thinking about assessments as a means to drive feedback, NOW you’re on to something.”

mic

Alternative Strategies for Assessing Learning: Larry Ferlazzo Classroom Q & A Podcast

By on March 30, 2016

“Whether they’re doing a portfolio or a performance task, they still want to see How do I stack up?” I had a lot of fun being interviewed for Larry Ferlazzo’s podcast about alternatives to grading and traditional assessments.  The follow-up

Pannello blog

Kids Speak Out on Student Engagement

By on March 10, 2016

Hey, middle school and high school teachers and parents!  Can you do me a favor? I am polling thousands of kids nationwide on what engages them the most in how they learn.  This is based on a survey of 500

Pannello blog

Pencils to 3D-Printers: A New Kind of Language Arts Class

By on February 7, 2016

  “The printers have been ordered.  Fingers crossed.  Here we go…..” This was the email I received two weeks ago from my principal who is working with me to develop a whole new kind of Language Arts class.  The plan

The sexy Ultimaker 2

Eeny, Meeny, Mino, Moe: Which 3D Printer Should We Own?

By on January 27, 2016

A couple weeks ago, I wrote about the start of my journey to create a Language Arts and ELD class that leveraged 3D printing as a means to initiate a more purposeful curriculum for reading and writing.  I will be

Screen Shot 2015-12-17 at 7.20.04 PM

5 Nonfiction Articles + Novels Series: Middle School Edition (Jan.)

By on January 20, 2016

Mutually Beneficial Animal Relationships (Photos) Written by: Huffington Post Staff Published On: The Huffington Post “The ostrich isn’t very good at smelling, while the zebra can smell pretty well. The zebra though, doesn’t have good eyesight, but the ostrich does.

IMG_5182

Making, Writing, & Leaving My Wheelhouse: How This Relates to ELD Students (UPDATED)

By on January 10, 2016

I first began blogging to reflect on what I was learning during my summer with the Writing Project. After each day, I returned home, head spinning, needing to simply process. Finally, my husband said, “Why don’t you try starting one

Pannello blog

5 Non-Fiction Articles to Pair with High School Literature (December)

By on December 23, 2015

    1. Dumb Kids’ Class Written by: Mark Bowden Published on: The Atlantic “My bet is that when a comprehensive inventory is made of my generation, it will be found that not one person from a smart kids’ class

Screen Shot 2015-12-17 at 7.20.04 PM

5 Nonfiction + Novels Series: The Middle School Edition for Dec. 2015

By on December 22, 2015

My newest post is the first in a series  in which I’m collaborating with Talks with Teachers podcaster and blogger, Brian Sztabnik. Brian not only moderates the #aplitchat on Twitter but also writes the 5 Nonfiction + Novels series for

Pannello blog

Celebrating the Refugees Already in Our Classrooms: Memories and Advice From a Student

By on December 1, 2015

In June 2001, a family of four escaped from the slaughter of Nepal and made their way across the world to safety. They arrived, not in boats dragged up on shore, but in the arms of families who helped them

Pannello blog

The Invisible Strategies of Teaching: #whatpeopledontsee

By on November 23, 2015

hen you walk onto a middle school campus and even into the rooms themselves, it can look like chaos. After all, middle schoolers are wired to be active and wired to be loud. But that doesn’t mean there isn’t learning

Screen Shot 2015-09-02 at 8.03.55 PM

Who Was I In Middle School? A Reflection + Free Downloadable

By on November 10, 2015

t times, seeing the diversity in my own students, I’ve wondered who I was when I was in middle school and what really drove my tween’s brain.  So I created a Tip 10 list of memories to help me reflect

Pannello blog

Boy Talk at Recess: Pokemon, Light Sabers, and Things That Go Boom!

By on October 11, 2015

y most recent post for The Huffington Post just went live.  It chronicles my embarrassment when my 9-year-old son chose his classroom’s parent-led art session to voice his recent interest in bloody talk.  It also chronicles my son’s frustration at

Screen Shot 2015-09-02 at 7.58.49 PM

DIY Project Based Learning for ELA and History

By on August 16, 2015

’m excited to announce that my new book, DIY Project Based Learning for ELA and History has arrived and is now available for purchase. The point of the book was to break down the process of PBL into day-by-day chunks

imgres

How to Host a Twitter Chat with your School Community

By on August 9, 2015

very year schools sit and brainstorm ways to communicate and engage its families. How will we reach out to parents? How will we gather information about their needs or give them a little insight in what we do as educators? A

Screen Shot 2015-07-26 at 10.00.17 AM

Lessons Students Can Learn From Mick Fanning vs. The Great White Shark

By on July 27, 2015

hat’s with shark videos? First it was the uniqueness of Left Shark in the Katy Perry halftime show. From him we learned to dance to your own groove, even in front of millions of people And now we have the

Courtesy of Marvel Studios and IMDB

Using Ant-Man In The Classroom

By on July 24, 2015

just watched Ant-Man with my 9 year-old, and we both walked away with a cinematic smile on our faces. For him, it was a movie of laughs and of just the right level of suspense. It didn’t have the darkness

Spiros-Steel-e1367528802634-300x300

The Full Interview with Dr. Spiros Michalakis

By on October 30, 2014

s part of my recent superhero PBL unit, I brought in Dr. Spiros Michalakis to talk to my students about research for their science-fiction based narratives.  Spiros is a Quantum Physicist who consulted on the new Marvel movie, Ant-man.  Sure,

15268475448_335a0b87a4_z

Visual of my Edutopia post: “The Power of I Don’t Know”

By on October 29, 2014

recently wrote an post for Edutopia called “The Power of I Don’t Know.”  It focuses on our need as teachers to release being the information authority in the room and instead to hand over the reins to the students themselves.